Strut Brands to Avoid: A Friendly Guide for Car Enthusiasts

Exploring the world of strut brands can be both confusing and overwhelming for car owners. Struts are a crucial component of a vehicle’s suspension system, responsible for maintaining stability and balance while driving.

Considering its role in your car’s performance, it is essential to choose wisely when it comes to replacing or upgrading your struts.

Many factors can influence the performance and durability of struts, and unfortunately, not all strut brands are created equal.

Some strut brands might fall short in terms of quality and longevity, and it’s vital to identify the ones you need to avoid. Being informed will not only save you time and money but also ensure the safety and proper functioning of your vehicle.

Strut Brands to Avoid

Importance of Struts in a Vehicle

Comfortable Ride

  • Struts are a crucial part of the vehicle’s suspension system.
  • They minimize vibration and absorb road bumps, providing a smoother ride.
  • Without struts, you would feel every single bump on the road, turning your daily commute into an unpleasant experience.

Handling

  • Struts help maintain tire contact with the road surface.
  • Better tire grip results in improved vehicle stability and handling.
  • A well-functioning strut system ensures your car responds effectively to steering inputs and handles corners optimally.

Safety

  • Struts are essential for supporting the vehicle’s weight.
  • They reduce the risk of tire wear or suspension issues, increasing overall safety.
  • Properly functioning struts are crucial in ensuring safe driving by reducing the risk of vehicle breakdowns and accidents resulting from tire or suspension failures.

Qualities to Look for in Strut Brands

Durability

  • Look for thicker springs in struts for better durability and longevity.
  • Check for materials like steel that ensure robustness and resistance to wear.

For example, KYB and Monroe are known for their durable products.

Performance

  • A quality strut should enhance ride comfort and handling.
  • Struts designed with advanced-valve technology can adapt to varying road conditions, ensuring consistent performance.

For instance, Bilstein and Rancho’s performance struts come with such features.

Compatibility

  • Always make sure that the strut is compatible with your vehicle’s make and model.
  • Struts designed for specific vehicles provide optimum performance and fit.

A simple comparison table for two popular strut brands:

BrandDurabilityPerformanceCompatibility
KYBHighGoodSpecific Models
BilsteinGoodHighSpecific Models

Remember to choose a strut brand based on its durability, performance, and compatibility with your vehicle.

Strut Brands to Avoid

Strut Brands to Avoid

Monroe: Monroe struts have mixed reviews. Some customers report premature wear and limited durability.

KYB: KYB struts, although popular, can be pricier than competitors. They may not be the best value for the money.

Moog: Moog struts may suffer from quality control issues. Instances of early failure have been reported.

CCIYU: CCIYU struts are known for their affordability. However, they may lack in quality and longevity.

Truedrive: Truedrive struts are also an affordable option but may need frequent replacements compared to other brands.

Mevotech: Mevotech struts can suffer from inconsistency. They might not be a dependable choice for all vehicles.

BrandProsCons
MonroeSome users report a good experiencePremature wear, limited durability
KYBPopular, wide range of applicationsPricier, may not offer the best value
MoogKnown for quality suspension componentsQuality control issues, early failures
CCIYUAffordableLacks quality and longevity
TruedriveLow-pricedFrequent replacements needed
MevotechUsed for various vehiclesInconsistency, might not be dependable

Reputable Strut Brands

Bavauto

  • Bavauto offers a range of struts for BMW, Mini, and other European vehicles.
  • They provide BAVAUTO Replacement Parts for those needing specific components.

OES

  • Original Equipment Supplier (OES) struts hold the advantage of being tailored to match your specific vehicle.
  • They maintain the same standards as the original manufacturer.

Bilstein

  • Bilstein is known for its high-performance suspension components, specifically their struts.
  • Their products are designed for better handling and control, offering enhanced driving comfort.

ACDelco

  • ACDelco struts cater to a variety of vehicles, including both GM and non-GM models.
  • ACDelco products are dependable and built with a focus on longevity.

Motorcraft

  • Motorcraft struts are tailored to Ford, Lincoln, and Mercury vehicles.
  • They are reliable options that help maintain factory performance levels.

OEM Sachs

  • OEM Sachs struts are used by car manufacturers like BMW, but have shortcomings in terms of durability for their price.
  • Though they claim to produce quality suspension parts, they may not be the most cost-effective choice.

Comparison Table

BrandProsCons
BavautoSpecialized for European vehiclesLimited range
OESMatch specific vehicle modelsMay be more expensive
BilsteinHigh-performance componentsMay not suit budget-conscious consumers
ACDelcoWide car model compatibilityGM preference
MotorcraftTailored to Ford, Lincoln, and Mercury modelsLimited to specific car brands
OEM SachsUsed by renowned car manufacturersDurability and price concerns

Signs of Bad Struts

Excessive Bouncing: When struts are worn out, the vehicle may bounce excessively after hitting a pothole or speed bump.

For example, if your car continues to bounce for a longer time than usual after driving over a rough patch, this could be a sign that the struts are not functioning properly.

Uneven tire wear: Worn-out or damaged struts can lead to uneven tire wear as they’re no longer able to properly support the weight of the vehicle.

For instance, you may observe uneven wear patterns on your tires, such as cupping or scalloping, which may indicate that the struts are not doing their job adequately.

Vibrations: A bad strut can create vibrations that can be felt through the steering wheel or in the cabin of the vehicle.

When you start to feel more vibrations in your car during a drive, particularly on a smooth road, it may be a sign of a bad strut.

SymptomBad Strut Example
Excessive BouncingProlonged bouncing after a pothole
Tire WearUneven wear patterns on tires
VibrationsFelt in steering wheel or cabin

Choosing the Best Strut Brands for Your Needs

When selecting strut brands, consider your specific requirements and preferences. Some drivers prefer a stiffer ride, while others prioritize a smooth, comfortable experience. Here are some factors to keep in mind:

  • Sturdy construction
  • Affordable prices
  • Availability for various car models

For example, Moog struts offer a great balance between sturdiness and affordability, making them a popular choice for car owners. Shock absorbers and strut mounts are essential considerations as well.

Comparison Table for Popular Strut Brands:

BrandSturdinessPriceSmooth RideStiffer Ride
KYBHighModerateYesNo
MoogHighLowNoYes
Sachs (OEM)ModerateHighYesNo

Make sure to weigh the pros and cons of each brand based on your individual needs and prioritize features most important to you.

Strut Brands to Avoid

Replacement and Installation Considerations

Replacing and installing new struts is an important maintenance task. It’s wise to choose hydraulic struts, as they provide smoother rides and better dynamics. When you need replacement struts, make sure to check the condition of bushings, too. Worn bushings may affect the performance of struts.

Strut TypeProsCons
HydraulicSmooth ride, better dynamicsMay wear out faster
GasFirmer ride, longer lifespanHarsher ride quality

Before changing or replacing struts, consider the following aspects:

  • Material: Durable materials ensure long-lasting performance
  • Brand reputation: Well-known brands usually offer better quality and support
  • Compatibility: Check the compatibility with the make and model of your car
  • Warranty: A good warranty indicates the manufacturer’s trust in their product

Some characteristics to look for in replacement struts:

  • Resistance to corrosion
  • Quality of the springs
  • Build quality and construction
  • Proper fitment and easy installation

Strut replacements can be a challenge if you’re not familiar with the components and tools involved. It helps to research reviews and installation guides for a better understanding of the process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which struts should I avoid for my car?

OEM Sachs Struts can be costly and may lack durability for their price.

What are some low-quality strut brands?

Certain strut brands like OEM Sachs Struts have a reputation for being low-quality.

Are there any affordable yet reliable strut brands?

Yes, there are affordable and reliable strut brands, such as Monroe Shocks & Struts and KYB.

How do I choose the best strut brand for my vehicle?

To choose the best strut brand for your vehicle, simply research various brands and compare their specifications.

What are the common problems with low-quality struts?

Some common problems associated with low-quality struts include poor ride quality and reduced lifespan.

Which strut brands are known for their durability?

Bilstein Shocks and KYB Shocks & Struts are known for their durability.

BrandDurability
Bilstein ShocksHigh
KYB Shocks & StrutsHigh
Monroe Shocks & StrutsMedium
OEM Sachs StrutsLow

Conclusion

Choosing the right strut brand is crucial for the performance and safety of your vehicle’s suspension system. By avoiding low-quality brands and opting for reputable and durable options, you can ensure a smooth and reliable driving experience. Prioritize quality, compatibility, and durability when selecting strut brands for your vehicle.

Photo of author

Sean Mendez

Hi, I am Sean, a self-confessed petrolhead. I live in Boise, Idaho with a busy family of four and our energetic Labrador retriever. Thank you for visiting my website. You can find my email on the contact page.

Leave a Comment